DDR-ARCV / 001Doordoorium

A dispute · spans 4 eras

Does God Exist?

Three families of argument, three centuries of counter-argument.

The classical theistic proofs come in three flavors: ontological (from the very concept of God — Anselm, Descartes), cosmological (from the existence of anything contingent — Aquinas, Leibniz), and teleological (from the apparent design of the world — Aquinas, Paley). Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion devastated the design argument; Kant showed the ontological argument illegitimately treats existence as a predicate; Russell publicly debated the cosmological argument with Father Copleston in 1948. The arguments still have defenders. They still have critics. Nobody has knocked the other side out.

◇ ◇ ◇

// The sides

Theist arguments

Reason supports belief in God.

Critiques

The classical arguments fail.