DDR-ARCV / 001Doordoorium

A dispute · spans 2 eras

The Mind-Body Problem

How do mind and matter relate? Are they two things, or one, or neither?

Descartes' dualism — mind and body as utterly different substances — generates the problem more than it solves it: how can two such alien stuffs interact? Spinoza answers: they are not two stuffs but two aspects of one. Leibniz answers: they don't interact at all; God pre-coordinates them. Hume bypasses the question by dissolving the mind into a bundle. The 20th century re-poses the problem as the hard problem of consciousness: how does any arrangement of matter give rise to experience?

◇ ◇ ◇

// The sides

Dualism

Mind and body are different substances.

Monism

Mind and body are aspects of one underlying reality.

Pre-established harmony

They don't interact; God synchronizes them.